Sewage at Swartruggens Water Works flowing straight into the Eland River. (James de Villiers, News24)
If a latest North West Excessive Courtroom judgment giving the ratepayers’ affiliation of Kgetlengrivier management of the water and sewage works is learn within the context of a basic decline within the provision of companies across the nation, it could possibly be an invite to South Africans to debate new methods of electing representatives, writes Mpumelelo Mkhabela.
A brand new manner of governing the nation could possibly be within the making. It goes like this. Each 5 years, hundreds of politicians across the nation persuade hundreds of thousands of voters to place them into energy on the endeavor that they are going to ship top-quality companies in numerous municipalities.
Earlier than the five-year time period is out, it turns into obvious that the one factor the profitable politicians and the bureaucrats they make use of know is to safe positions of energy for themselves. As soon as in energy, the politicians who sweet-talked their manner into council chambers are solely comfortable to get salaries and extra advantages that include controlling the purse strings of municipalities.
By means of this energy, they distribute patronage within the type of jobs and tenders for mates, members of the family and political allies. In follow, stuffing their pockets with ratepayers’ cash and diverting a few of it to pay for his or her subsequent spherical of campaigns to return to energy is their vicious raison d’être. Put merely, they exist just for that goal, nothing else.
The politicians do not add worth to resident and enterprise ratepayers who sweat to earn an earnings, solely to have it diverted for the self-serving political ends of incompetent politicians. Not solely does service supply grow to be poorer or cease as a consequence; it actually regresses as unmaintained infrastructure falls aside.
However as a result of South Africa is just not (but) Zimbabwe, the place the ruling celebration has efficiently overwhelmed nearly your entire inhabitants into silence and compelled hundreds of thousands overseas, a number of residents organise themselves into civil society teams. They name themselves the ratepayers’ affiliation.
Push for a functioning system
They’re normally not considering celebration politics, however they wish to see the charges they pay ploughed again into their residential properties and companies within the type of streets with out potholes, functioning sewage programs and an ample provide of unpolluted ingesting water. Upon realising that the democratically elected politicians are good at convincing unsuspecting voters to place them into energy however are ineffective at performing primary duties prescribed in legislation, the ratepayers’ affiliation lodges complaints to the court docket and asks for treatments.
The court docket offers the municipality involved time to repair the issue, failing which the capabilities they’re meant to carry out beneath the management of the sweet-talking politicians, are ceded to the ratepayers’ affiliation.
A latest case examine is that of the ANC-controlled Kgetlengrivier Native Municipality in North West. For years, the municipality has didn’t handle sewage and water programs. Sewage flows liberally into the streets and streams inflicting environmental hurt.
The municipality has dismally failed to offer clear water and different primary companies – the very issues for which a municipality exists. Final month, the Kgetlengrivier Ratepayers’ Affiliation formally took over management of water and sewage provision from the municipality after the North West Excessive Courtroom dominated in its favour in a precedent-setting judgment in December 2020.
The court docket dominated that the affiliation has a proper to obtain the companies of consultants to repair sanitation and water provision. Nonetheless, the municipality will foot the payments.
The ruling raises sensible and theoretical questions on democracy. What it actually means is that electoral outcomes that put lives in danger might be put apart in favour of a judicially sanctioned possibility that may enhance lives. Now, all of the sudden an enormous part of the duty of democratically elected officers has been ceded to a non-elected affiliation by a court docket in an endeavour to safe the rights of all residents to have entry to water and be free from sewage hazards.
Though it stays to be seen, there’s a actual risk that the affiliation may competently execute the capabilities given to it by the court docket. If this have been to occur, the elected politicians would have confirmed themselves incompetent in comparison with the technocratically pushed ratepayers’ affiliation, who needs to see worth within the charges it’s paying.
In concept, democracy is supposed to boost public legitimacy of determination making and it offers voters with the dignity of getting a say on who governs them and the way. Textbook democratic concept assumes that common elections present a platform for residents to vary events or public representatives who fail of their job. It’s anticipated that residents would accordingly change incompetent representatives.
However there is no such thing as a reply to the dilemma of the continual retention of incapable governments in municipalities at each election. May it’s that residents or the vast majority of them are entitled to their democratic proper to be robbed of primary companies by the politicians they admire?
Even when it is accepted that that is the case, what in regards to the minority who don’t wish to be a part of such a perverse association between the bulk and the incapable, however democratically elected politicians? Representatives of the North West authorities, the native municipality and the ANC-aligned South African Municipal Employees’ Union (Samwu) have criticised the judgment, citing the democratic proper to manipulate.
The affiliation, however, needs companies which people who have a democratic proper to manipulate are failing to offer. But, these companies are an entitlement when it comes to the Invoice of Rights.
Whether it is learn within the context of a basic decline within the provision of companies across the nation, the North West Excessive Courtroom judgment could possibly be an invite to South Africans to debate new methods of electing representatives. A system that balances democratic rule and technical capability of the people we elect into positions of energy. Name it a technocracy or another title.
– Mpumelelo Mkhabela is a former parliamentary correspondent, editor of The Sowetan and a political analyst.
*Friday Briefing on 19 February 2020 will take the reader to Koster and Swartruggens within the North West to present an in-depth view of what the ratepayers affiliation has achieved because the court docket ruling. There may even be skilled evaluation on whether or not we want authorities in gentle of the court docket judgment.
To obtain the Friday Briefing, sign up for the newsletter here. Now out there to all News24 readers.
*Wish to reply to the columnist? Ship your letter or article to firstname.lastname@example.org along with your title and city or province. You’re welcome to additionally ship a profile image. We encourage a range of voices and views in our readers’ submissions and reserve the best to not publish any and all submissions acquired.
Disclaimer: News24 encourages freedom of speech and the expression of various views. The views of columnists revealed on News24 are due to this fact their very own and don’t essentially symbolize the views of News24.